Add a post-mortem, crudely

This commit is contained in:
Jahn 2025-08-02 22:23:31 -04:00
parent 42caa9e724
commit e77304dc87
2 changed files with 34 additions and 0 deletions

View File

@ -14,3 +14,35 @@ Objects move on their own. You only control the ~~pencil~~ pen.
* multipliers for combos
* penalties for not-combos
* ignore all erroneous gestures, gesture recognition is probably my fault
# CANCELED
A brief post-mortem.
## What Went Wrong
It's had been a minute since I attempted a proper game jam, and while I could tell I was much more
*skilled* this time around, my *execution* was what caused this fumble. I've been programming mostly
websites (server-side and client-side), applications, and tooling. *Games are a different,
cross-disciplinary beast.*
* Stick to the plan. The plan was visual metaphor to game ideas to game. I discarded all metaphor planning
in favor of a novel UI, which has worked in the past but this time set me back.
* Too much emphasis on doing something differently, rather than well. Yes, most of my initial ideas
were also built around by other developers and teams. No, that doesn't mean we'd be making the same
game. Build games that interest you, that you want to play, and fit your scope. Doesn't matter if
it's *unique.* This game isn't being presented to a general audience (yet)
* Core gameplay of mechanic was not considered enough before starting. Should have paper-tested it,
would have likely found it more akin to Fruit Ninja than a Wario Ware game.
* Too much aesthetic, too soon. Focusing on the smaller details (theming, sprites, UI) before ironing
out the large ones. This is a great little morale boost, but it is too much commitment too early on.
## What Went Right
I don't think the initial approach was wrong, however I think I rushed into starting too soon. I initially
just wrote down a bunch of visual metaphors for loops on paper and thought about each one in the context
of a game. I had 8, with a nebulous mound of ideas using them. I went on to observe many other teams make
games using some permutation of those same 8 metaphors.
* Spend time really considering the theme. As much as you can.
* Come up with many metaphors, not just one. It doesn't start with a game idea, necessarily, it starts with
an analogy.
* Come up with *game concepts* for each before proceeding. As many as you can, but don't spend too
much time on dead ends. I did this, but I didn't write it down.

View File

@ -8,6 +8,7 @@ size = Vector2(48, 46)
[sub_resource type="Animation" id="Animation_dtuyt"]
resource_name = "Walking"
loop_mode = 1
tracks/0/type = "value"
tracks/0/imported = false
tracks/0/enabled = true
@ -126,3 +127,4 @@ texture = ExtResource("2_dtuyt")
libraries = {
&"": SubResource("AnimationLibrary_5hcc2")
}
autoplay = "Walking"